Villain by Choice, Good Person by Nature

Villain by Choice, Good Person by Nature

Grab a coffee—or a glass of wine, I’m not judging—and settle in. We need to have a little chat about perspective.

You’ve heard the rumors, right? Maybe you’ve seen the “look” I give when someone cuts the line at the grocery store, or you’ve heard a filtered version of a fallout I had with someone back in the day. Depending on who you ask, I’m either the salt of the earth or the salt rubbed directly into a wound.

The Truth About Having a Big Heart

And honestly? I don’t care if I’m the villain in your story. I know, I know. That sounds a bit “Disney Queen” of me. But here is the tea: I am a really good person. I have an extremely good heart. I’m the person who will venmo you for lunch before you even realize you forgot your wallet, and I’m the first one at your door with a box of tissues and bad movies when your life falls apart. My heart is big—it’s just not a doormat.

When Setting Boundaries Makes You the “Bad Guy”

Why do people cast me as the antagonist? Usually, it’s because I have this “annoying” habit called setting boundaries. In a world where everyone wants you to say “yes” until you burn out, saying “no” makes you the bad guy. If I stop giving 100% to someone who is giving me 0%, suddenly I’m “cold.” If I call out a lie instead of nodding politely to keep the peace, I’m “difficult.”

Here’s the thing about being the villain: it’s usually a title given to you by someone who couldn’t control you.

If I’m Your Villain, You Probably Deserved It

I’m just being honest here! I don’t go looking for dragons to slay. I’m actually very tired and would prefer to be napping. But if I’ve reached the point where I’m the “antagonist” in your narrative, we have to look at the prequel.

The Prequel to the Antagonist

• Did you mistake my kindness for weakness? • Did you think my “good heart” meant I wouldn’t notice the disrespect? • Did you think you could keep taking without ever giving back?

If I finally stood up, walked away, or closed the door, and that made me the “mean one” in your retelling of the story… well, I hope the character development serves you well. I’m a firm believer that if I’m the villain in your story, you probably earned that status through a series of very specific, very questionable choices.

A Good Heart Needs a Strong Ribcage

Having a good heart doesn’t mean being a saint. It means caring deeply, acting with integrity, and wanting the best for people. But a good heart also needs a ribcage to protect it.

I’ve realized that I’d rather be “the villain” and have my peace of mind than be “the sweetheart” and be miserable. I’m still Tina. I’m still going to help the elderly lady with her bags, and I’m still going to cry at dog commercials. My essence hasn’t changed; my tolerance for nonsense has just hit a record low.

Welcome to the Villain Club

We’ve all been there, haven’t we? You try to be the bigger person until you realize the bigger person just gets used as a bridge for people to walk over. Then, the moment you stand up, you’re the monster.

So, to anyone currently being painted as the “bad guy” because you finally stood your ground: Welcome to the club. We have snacks, and the view is much better from over here where we aren’t being exploited.

I’m at peace with my role. If your story needs a villain to make your own mistakes feel better, you can use my name. I know the truth, my real friends know the truth, and my dog definitely knows I’m a hero (mostly because I drop pieces of cheese).

Bottom line: I’ll keep my good heart, and you can keep your script. Just don’t be surprised when the “villain” doesn’t show up for the sequel.

What about you? Have you ever been cast as the “villain” just for standing up for yourself? Let’s swap “evil” stories in the comments.

10 thoughts on “Villain by Choice, Good Person by Nature

  1. my story doesn’t need a villain, Oh, it kinda does. The one I was writing today is a villain with no empathy. You know the psychopathic type.

    Sorry you seem too nice for that role.

    1. Haha, I’ll take ‘too nice’ as a compliment, though my characters might disagree! Sometimes the most dangerous villains are the ones who know exactly how to be kind before they strike. 😉 Good luck with your psychopathic type—those are always chilling to write!

  2. Yes, I was cast as the villain. What was worse is that everyone would take the other person’s side, including those in authority and all gang up on me. (not physically but I’m sure you know what I mean.)

    1. I really appreciate your insight. It’s a harsh reality that once a group decides on a ‘villain,’ they often stop looking for the truth. That feeling of being ganged up on is something many people overlook when they talk about conflict. It takes a lot of resilience to navigate that kind of social pressure.

    1. I completely agree. There is a certain peace that comes when your actions finally align with how others see you. Validation isn’t always necessary, but it certainly helps the journey feel less lonely. Thanks for reading and for sharing your perspective!

Leave a Reply

Back to top

Discover more from Stories From Tina

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading

Discover more from Stories From Tina

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading